Our Voices The Orinam Blog

Letter to World Psychiatric Association: Feb 3, 2014

India-medic

 

Preface: In activism, as in science, results are rarely attributable to a single event or person.  In the case of the Indian Psychiatric Society’s public statement on homosexuality, it is likely that many events and activist efforts resulted in this response: media coverage of homophobic statements by Immediate Past President Dr. Indira Sharma that provoked public outrage, the protests by IPS members and resignation from IPS of psychiatrists in Kolkata in protest against IPS’ not taking a public stance, the dissemination of results from a Samapathik Trust survey carried out at the IPS annual meeting in Pune last month, and ambiguous messages carried in a ToI interview of the General Secretary in Visakhapatnam that elicited further communication to IPS.

Many individuals, LGBT and heterosexual, health professionals and lay persons, have written to the IPS and to the World Psychiatric Association (WPA) seeking public clarification of their stance.

We reproduce below one such letter, written to the President, World Psychiatric Association on Mon, Feb 3, 2014, three days before IPS made a public announcement of their stand. We also present the follow-up responses from WPA and IPS.

We invite other individuals and groups who have made similar interventions to share them for the public record, to enable us archive these moments in the history of LGBT activism in India.


Dr. Indira Sharma’s homophobic comment: A petition from scientists, professionals and other concerned individuals

February 3, 2013

Prof. Dinesh Bhugra
President Elect
World Psychiatric Association

Dear Professor Bhugra,

We write to you as scientists, professionals and concerned individuals who are members and allies of the lesbian-gay-bisexual-transgender communities in India.

We are deeply concerned by the homophobic remarks made by Dr. Indira Sharma, Immediate Past President of the Indian Psychiatric Society and current President (as per IPS website http://www.ips-online.org/) of the SAARC Psychiatric Federation. At a panel discussion on homosexuality and Section 377 that was part of the recently concluded 66th Annual National Conference of IPS held in Pune this January, Dr. Sharma, who is a child psychiatrist, termed homosexuality as unnatural, and followed this up with comments to a leading national daily newspaper stating:

“The manner in which homosexuals have brought the talk of sex to the roads makes people uncomfortable. It’s unnatural. Our society doesn’t talk about sex. Heterosexuals don’t talk about sex. It’s a private matter,”… “There are some who are comfortable, but there are many who are not. The latter should realize they can get help (from psychiatrists). Some of them may even be able to change their orientation,” Sharma said. She added that those comfortable with their orientation should be made aware that their behaviour was causing a lot of uneasiness in society.  – Homosexuality is unnatural, leading psychiatrist says [Iyer, 2014].

Our concerns around her statements at the conference and to the press stem from the following:

 (i) Dr. Sharma’s views – coming from a child psychiatrist –   go against the grain of current scientific and psychiatric opinion, can cause immense harm to potential clients, and will infuse false hope among parents and family members of lesbian, gay and bisexual children that homosexual orientation is responsive to medical intervention. It has been well documented that anxious parents in India drag their children to psychiatrists to “cure” any symptom of gender-nonconformity or homosexual behaviour, and there exist several unscrupulous clinicians who use everything from anti-depressants to electro-shock therapy to try and reduce the clients’ same-sex desire [Chandran, 2013]. We are apprehensive of the potential harm to the mental health LGB youth that is likely to result from her statements.

 (ii) As a spokesperson of the Indian Psychiatric Society, Dr. Sharma’s opinions run counter to the Society’s views as articulated in compelling editorials by Professors Rao and Jacob in the official journal Indian Journal of Psychiatry, in which the authors argue for psychiatrists to understand homosexuality as just another variant of human sexuality, and to desist from attempts to change sexuality [Rao and Jacob, 2012, 2014]

(iii)  As the SAARC Psychiatric Federation, of which Dr. Sharma is reportedly the President, is affiliated with the World Psychiatric Association, we believe her publicly aired professional views do major disservice in misrepresenting psychiatric opinion on the issue, jeopardising WPA’s mission to advance psychiatry and mental health across the world.

(iv) In the current Indian socio-legal context,  our LGBT communities are struggling to sway the obsolent colonial legacy that is our sodomy law in the direction of justice, by battling the Supreme Court verdict on Section 377. Notwithstanding the fact that a team of mental health professionals has filed a review petition urging the Supreme Court to reconsider its decisions, we fear that front-page newspaper pronouncements of the kind made by Dr. Sharma risk fortifying popular prejudice with the appearance of scientific support – which is both false and misleading.

Out of this concern, we wrote a mail to Indian Psychiatric Society and the present President has clarified via email  that Dr. Sharma’s view is her own and the society does not endorse it [Orinam, 2014]. However, we are yet to see a public statement or press release to this effect.

We are thus writing to you in hopes that WPA and SAARC Psychiatric Federation would consider taking a public stand on the ‘naturalness’ of homosexuality and on “curative”/”reparative” therapy, and that such a stand is made available to the public and LGBT communities in India. A letter to the Editor, TOI, or a statement in a professional journal, bulletin or website,  will help a lot.

Thanking you,

Sincerely yours,

Dr. Abhijit Majumder, Early Career Fellow, Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine, Bangalore.
Dr. L. Ramakrishnan, Solidarity and Action Against The HIV Infection in India (SAATHII), Chennai
Dr. Mohinish Shukla, Assistant Professor, Dept. of Psychology, UMass
Boston, Boston, USA
Prof. Jyotsna Dhawan, Scientist and Ex-Dean, Institute for Stem Cell
Biology and Regenerative Medicine, Bangalore.
Dr. Rajnish Rao, Postdoctoral Researcher, Bernstein Center for Computational
Neuroscience,Humboldt University of Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Dr. Ipsita Pal, Fellow, John Hopkins University, USA
Dr. Aditya K. Sengupta, Avesthagen Ltd, India.
Dr. Hari Easwaran, Asst. Professor, Oncology, Johns Hopkins University,
Baltimore, MD, USA
Dr. Venkatesh Acharya, Senior Designer Engineer, Texas Instuments, USA.
Dr. Vineet Gaur, Postdoctoral researcher, International institute of
molecular and cell biology, Warsaw, Poland.
Dr Gurjot Singh, Project Associate, Divecha Centre for Climate Change,
Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore.
Dr. Subhojit Sen, Ramalingaswamy Fellow, Center for Excellence in Basic
Sciences, Mumbai University, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Dr. Rajeeb K Swain, Ramalingaswami Fellow, Institute of Life Sciences, India.
Shishir Thadani, Retired Telecom Consultant, Former Manager Quality
Assurance and Product Support, Siemens Santa Clara, CA
Dr. Nishad Matange, Research Associate, Division of Biological Sciences,
IISc, Bangalore.
Dr. Ramkumar Sambasivan, Scientist, InStem, Bangalore.
Dr Ritwick Sawarkar, Group Leader, ETH-Zurich, Switzerland and Max Planck
Institute of Immunobiology and Epigenetics, Germany.
Deepanjan Saha, City Planner, Delhi Development Authority, Delhi.
Manish Gautam, External Consultant, Indian Institute for Human
Settlements, Bangalore City Campus, Bangalore.
Nabil Khan, Harvard Divinity School, USA.
Kaveri Rajaraman, Center for Neural and Cognitive Sciences, Central
University of Hyderabad
Karthik Rao Cavale, PhD Student, MIT, USA.
Asha Gopinathan, Consultant, GenSci-e-Tech, Trivandrum, India.
Bodhisatwa Chaudhuri, PhD Student, Centre for Neuroscience, IISc
Varun Pattabhiraman, Research Scientist, Amazon.com
Anuj Menon, PhD Student, JNCASR, Bangalore
Pronoy Rai, Teaching Assistant & PhD Student, Department of Geography, and Unit for Criticism and Interpretive Theory, University of Illinois, IL, USA.
Devesh Radhakrishnan, PhD candidate, Department of Chemical and
Biomolecular Engineering, University of Delaware, Newark, DE.
Shinjini Basu, Project Assistant, Centre for High Energy Physics, IISc
Mrinmaya Sachan, PhD Student, School of Computer Science, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Nimisha Agarwal, PhD scholar, National Institute of Advanced Studies,
Bangalore
Vinodh Ilangovan, Graduate Student, Max Planck Institute for Biophysical
Chemistry, Goettingen, Germany.
Shantanu Kumar, software developer, Netherlands.
Srinivas Muktha, R&D Engineer, Bangalore.
Sheeraz Ahmad, PhD student, University of California, San Diego.
Ayan Roychowdhury, PhD Student, Mechanical Engineering Department, IIT Kanpur.
Manas Modi, Interaction Designer, User Experience team, Flipkart.com,
Bengaluru.
Sumit, UG student at IIT Roorkee, CSI-V, Roorkee, Uttarakhand, India-247667
Abhinav Aggarwal, UG student at IIT Roorkee, CSI-V, Roorkee, Uttarakhand, India-247667
Abhinav Rajagopalan, UG student at IIT Bombay, Powai, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
Shreekant Deodhar, PhD Student, Center for Ecological Sciences, Indian
Institute of Science.

References:

Chandran. Vinay. 2013. From judgement to practice: Section 377 and the medical sector. Indian Journal of Medical Ethics. Vol X No. 4 October-December 2013 http://www.issuesinmedicalethics.org/174co198.html

Iyer, Malathi. 2014. Homosexuality is unnatural, leading psychiatrist says. Times of India. Jan 21, 2014 http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2014-01-21/india/46410477_1_orientation-dr-indira-sharma-ips

Orinam. 2014. IPS clarifies: Dr. Indira Sharma’s View on Homosexuality is Not the Official View. Orinam blog Jan 22, 2014. http://orinam.net/indira-sharma-homosexuality/

Sathyanarayana Rao T S, Jacob K S. 2012. Homosexuality and India. Indian J Psychiatry [serial online] 2012. 54:1-3. http://www.indianjpsychiatry.org/text.asp?2012/54/1/1/94636

Sathyanarayana Rao T S, Jacob K S. 2014. The reversal on Gay Rights in India. Indian J Psychiatry [serial online] 2014. 56:1-2. http://www.indianjpsychiatry.org/text.asp?2014/56/1/1/124706


Postscript: We reviewed an immediate response from the WPA President-Elect stating that he has “forwarded it to the WPA secretariat so that this can be discussed at length at the next Executive Committee. These matters are led by the President of the WPA, Professor Ruiz, who is aware of the situation.” Professor Bhugra further suggested the petitioners  write to the President of the Indian Psychiatric Society and Chair of the Medical Council of India.

A follow-up letter by Dr. Majumder to the IPS President, on  February 5, 2014, following the General Secretary’s TOI interview, fetched the following response “We will be stating IPS statement soon (before evening). Thanks for the mail.I am sure that the prevailing issues would be sorted out.”

On February 6, 2014, the IPS official statement was released.

Comments

2 Comments. Add your own »

Comment Guidelines: Your email address will not displayed. Your comment may be held up for moderation. Language that is deemed unsuitable for decent discussion will be expunged. Avoid pasting raw URLs or large quotations from elsewhere. The opinions expressed here are those of the respective individuals. We reserve the right to take down irrelevant and improper comments without any notice.

  1. Message from Samapathik Trust: For the past 12 years IPS did not have a stand on homosexuality.
    It was after-
    1. Samapathik Trusts’ survey on IPC377 with Psychiatrists at IPS Annual National Conference in Jan 2014 (please see results on FB- Samapathik-Trust-Pune)
    2. Homophobic interview by Dr. Indira Sharma following the conference
    3. Samapathik Trust issuing a letter to IPS President- Dr. Asokan thru the vice president Dr. Vatve stating that IPs make its stand clear within 30 days.(please see FB- Samapathik-Trust-Pune)
    4. Samapathik Trust having a press conference seeking clarification on these issues. (please see FB- Samapathik-Trust-Pune)
    5. Samapathik Trust writing to World Psychiatrist Association stating that -it is shameful that in the past 12 years IPS has not made a formal position on this issue- (which probably upset the IPS).
    6. Various liberal Psychiatrists writing to World Psychiatrist Association and fighting with IPS on this that this success has been achieved.
    Regards
    Bindumadhav Khire
    President
    Samapathik Trust, Pune

  2. Thank you for sharing the information above. One question. Do the two editorials in Indian Journal of Psychiatry, being the official journal of IPS, count as the official opinion of IPS? If they do count, is it accurate to say that IPS has not taken a stand on homosexuality in the last twelve years?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *